crime scene investigation

Crime Scene Investigation (CSI): Truth vs. Fiction

What every cop wants you to know about CSI

It didn’t take long.

The television show, CSI, or “Crime Scene Investigation”, soared in popularity quickly from the start.

Americans love cop shows.

Almost every night of the week you can catch some variation of one. It was only a matter of time before someone would create a niche for the science behind cracking the tougher cases.

Like a force of nature, enter the weekly show CSI that quickly overtook all of its competitors.

I still remember the first time I tried to watch it. I don’t remember anything about the story. My only recollection was that I couldn’t make it to the first commercial. The absolute absurdity of their portrayal of forensics was too much.

Now I’m not here to bash the show. Millions of their rabid fans don’t care if it’s not 100 percent accurate.

This article’s true intention is to educate and make families aware of exactly what should be expected from forensic science. As always, this is not the end all or be all on this topic but it’s a good starting point.

Note: this post contains affiliate links

(Lookupfare is the only site I use when booking flights and making hotel reservations.) 

TV makes forensic crime scene investigations look too easy.

Your typical made for TV cop drama has to solve a crime in an incredibly short amount of time. If it’s an hour long episode, minus the commercials, it ends up being less than 45 minutes.

In reality it takes us that long to even figure out what the heck happened or at least an idea of what happened.

To process a crime scene for forensic evidence takes longer than your average citizen realizes. Especially when you have multiple scenes for one event.

Fingerprints

Lets use the example of a burglary.

You come home from a long 8 hour work day. As you pull into the driveway, you notice that your front door is wide open and looks like it has been kicked in.

You immediately suspect those two hoodlums your son has recently befriended. You call the police and demand that the entire house be checked for fingerprints and DNA.

Depending on the size of your house this could take a very LONG time. Lets start with fingerprinting.

To locate, lift and properly transfer a fingerprint onto a fingerprint card is extremely difficult. Most people think we can get fingerprints off of pretty much everything. I once had a victim demand that I get prints off of a pair of socks!

burglary

No. No we cannot.

Without getting overly technical, the only surfaces we can get prints from are those that are non-porous, like glass or other hard surfaces. We can’t get them off a shoe, toothbrush, wall, purse, wallet, etc.

Also, approximately 75 percent of the prints that are lifted are of no value.

Let me repeat.

75 PERCENT of the latent prints lifted are of NO VALUE.

Meaning, not enough of the print was recovered to compare it to another print or put in a database.

Oh and fingerprint dust is beyond messy (I really hope you don’t have a white shag carpet).

DNA

No facet of forensic science has been so glamorized or as misunderstood as DNA.

Some may argue but DNA was born into our collective consciousness during the O.J. Simpson murder trial. There was an overwhelming amount of DNA evidence presented during that trial. It was still early days for DNA back then in the early 90’s. Because of this, and the horrendous case put on by the prosecution, OJ was able to walk on a double homicide.

Today, that case would have never made it to trial.

O.J. would have plead to both and asked for life instead of the death penalty (that’s if California had a death penalty).

The biggest misconception that people have is that DNA can solve every case. This just isn’t the case (pun intended).

For starters, there has to be enough of the bad guys bodily fluids etc. for extraction that contains DNA for it to be useful.

One example is a lone strand of hair that may belong to your suspect.

This is not enough to extract DNA for a viable sample. The hair strand must contain the root of the hair follicle.

I am not trying to be Bart the Science guy here. Just helping you understand that TV shows can be misleading.

Reality

Any criminal investigation that uses forensic science as the sole basis for making a case is fighting an uphill battle.

The most laughable thing that TV shows like “CSI” completely whiff on is time. And the show “Dexter” does the same thing.

Meaning a DNA hit or match doesn’t happen as soon as they return to the office. And they can’t just submit a sample into a computer they keep at the police station.

I won’t get overly technical here but it typically takes months to get results.

And that is only IF there is a sample on file to compare to.

Now don’t get me wrong. If done properly, DNA evidence is the strongest out there. I have NEVER had a defendant challenge a case that had their DNA.

Not once.

Just remember, DNA is complicated and that it takes time to process.


Crime Scene Technicians 

This is probably the one thing that drives cops crazy when when watching these shows. Let me begin by saying I have nothing but the utmost respect for crime scene technicians. They have a thankless job working in the background to help detectives solve cases. They are relied upon heavily when no other evidence is available to solve a case.

The keyword is background.

Shows like “CSI” portray crime scene technicians with the same authority and job duties as police detectives.

Crime scene techs do not push the case detective to the side and tell them they are taking over the investigation. Or interrogate suspects.

It just doesn’t happen.

Now there may be one or two police departments that work on the cheap who combine the two. Those are an anomaly.


Are there any other TV shows that you are unable to watch? I would love to hear your comments. Please, no disdain or contrary opinions about the show “House”. I want to keep living in a world where there will always be a team of exceptional doctors trying to keep me alive!


Some of you have reached out and want to share your story with others. A blog like this one is a great way to reach those who could benefit from your experience and interests. Blogging has changed my perspective and my life.

It could do the same for you.

I recommend HostGatorwhich in my opinion is the simplest and fastest way to get you started on your blogging journey. If you have any questions about starting a blog or a website, please don’t hesitate to leave a comment or email me directly at bart@familysafefirst.com.



 

 

A 23-year veteran police officer, Bart spent time as a patrolmen and a violent crimes detective (specialized in strategic intelligence and research analysis). Aside from this experience in high profile case investigations, he has received training from the FBI and the Department of Homeland Security in Advanced Intelligence Analysis. Bart also holds a Bachelor of Science degree in Criminal Justice and Strategic Intelligence (Magna Cum Laude) from Liberty University. As a father of four, husband and law enforcement officer, he wants to share his knowledge on safety with you. Bart is also a contributing writer for Law Enforcement Today.

5 Comments

  • Marilyn Woodall February 10, 2017 at 6:27 pm

    This is exactly what every citizen needs to know. TV leads us to believe in make believe. Some programs like 48 Hours, The Justice Files etc. put things in a much better perspective and are actual cases that actually happened with real people. I think the public should know how real Police work actually gets done and that it is in real time and not tv time. Keep up the good truthful information to help educate the public. Thank you for caring about people and for all you do Bart.

    Reply
  • Bart Proctor February 10, 2017 at 7:00 pm

    Thank you Marilyn. I believe the misinformation about what exactly the police can do is troubling. My goal for the article is to educate families to what they can expect from the police and from forensics. Major cases never get solved as quickly as they do on TV.

    Reply
  • Marilyn Woodall February 28, 2017 at 4:36 am

    I think these are good points the public needs to know and I thank you for the info. How many DNA labs are there in the country and what is the average wait time to get it back?

    Reply
  • Misty Baez March 2, 2017 at 10:07 pm

    THANKS FOR SHARING THIS WITH US. I NEVER BELIEVED THAT IT WAS THAT EASY. I KEEP TRYING TO DRILL THE REALNESS OF THE WORLD TO MY TWO GRANDSONS THAT I’M RAISING. IT HAS ALWAYS BEEN CRIME IN THE STREETS, BUT ITS EVEN WORSE NOW A DAYS. THANKS AGAIN

    Reply
    • Bart Proctor March 3, 2017 at 7:41 am

      Thanks Misty. Sometimes the media can paint a picture that is not entirely accurate, especially cop shows. Good luck raising those two boys. I have three so I feel your pain! Have a great day and be safe!

      Reply

Leave a Reply